Ardent Justice Read online

  Ardent Justice

  Peter Taylor-Gooby

  Copyright © 2017 Peter Taylor-Gooby

  The moral right of the author has been asserted.

  Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers.

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, businesses, places, events and incidents are either the products of the author’s imagination or used in a fictitious manner. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental.

  Matador

  9 Priory Business Park,

  Wistow Road, Kibworth Beauchamp,

  Leicestershire. LE8 0RX

  Tel: 0116 279 2299

  Email: [email protected]

  Web: www.troubador.co.uk/matador

  Twitter: @matadorbooks

  ISBN 9781785897658

  British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data.

  A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

  Matador® is an imprint of Troubador Publishing Ltd

  To Sue

  - and thanks to Diane Dane, David Ewens, James Essinger, David Pick, Peter Smith and many others who helped me with this book.

  Author’s profits from this book will go to Shelter, the housing and homelessness charity.

  Registered charity in England and Wales (263710) and in Scotland (SC002327)

  Contents

  1

  2

  3

  4

  5

  6

  7

  8

  9

  10

  11

  12

  13

  14

  15

  16

  17

  18

  19

  20

  21

  22

  23

  24

  25

  26

  27

  28

  29

  30

  31

  32

  33

  34

  35

  36

  37

  Background Note

  About the Author

  1

  2

  1

  Ade stared at the man seated in the executive chair in front of the picture window, bright sunlight all round him. She hated him. She hated all of them, the smooth self-confident brokers and traders in their smart business suits, the smell of the cologne they wore, the way they brushed everything she said aside, their casual sexism. She hated their world, the secretaries in the outer office, always women, always stick-thin, always eighteen, running their eyes down her clothes, their perfect lips sneering at her grooming, the paid help in the back office who manufactured the accounts for them, the clubs where they did all the deals – word of mouth old boy, nothing on paper, never anything on paper.

  ‘My assessment stands,’ she said.

  He laughed as if they were sharing a joke. He took a silk handkerchief from his breast pocket and wiped it across his lips.

  ‘Tax,’ he said. ‘Tax. Where would we be without our tax-inspectors? It’s always a pleasure, young lady. But I agree nothing.’

  ‘Please examine the spreadsheet.’ She used her most formal voice but she was fumbling with the catch on the case of her lap-top. At last she got it open and swivelled it, so he could see the screen. ‘I have estimated all transactions for the past month from your clients’ records. You will see your estimated profits, your costs based on the standard model, and the tax liable.’

  His eyes flicked to a briefcase, top quality, with two high security combination locks, lying at the corner of the desk furthest from her. Then he reached past it and picked up a sheet of paper covered in numbers.

  ‘I see the Revenue has laptops now. Very modern.’ He grinned as if amused. ‘But I can’t agree those figures. Here are my accounts, very different. Certified of course. I think my accountant should join our discussion. I’m sure she’ll be able to explain everything. Thursday, 4.30? Then I could take you to dinner afterwards.’

  ‘Mr Webster.’

  ‘Call me Rex. I’ll call you Adeline.’

  ‘I cannot believe the rate of profit here is so low. You have some expensive art-work on your walls.’

  She gestured towards the picture dominating the room, chalk on black paper, a massive helmsman in oil-skins at the wheel of a clipper under full sail fighting its way through towering waves.

  ‘Tacita Dean, I think?’

  He smiled at her.

  ‘Your clients are wealthy. These offices are over £1700 a square metre.’

  She glanced out of the window, across the river to the dome of the cathedral, the cross glittering in the bright sunlight, the office-blocks towering over it.

  ‘You have a view.’

  She hated all of them. They always delayed, always produced a different assessment with costs that no one had ever thought of. Then you took the case before the Commissioners and you could see them sitting there, all men, all ex-business themselves, smiling and talking in their confident voices about their acquaintances, their schools, their clubs, about Monte Carlo and motor-racing and rugby.

  ‘How do you think the health service is financed, Mr Webster? Pensions? The roads you drive your cars on? Aid for starving children?’

  He grinned back at her and glanced at the photo in the leather frame on his desk, two smiling blond girls in identical school uniforms. ‘My daughters. Like peas in a pod aren’t they? Except that’s the one with leukaemia. Or is it that one, I’m never sure?’

  He chuckled.

  ‘Only kidding. Yes. I go private anyway. Makes sense. The NHS is all bureaucracy, waste of money.’

  You never had to sit there with your mother when she had the fall. You never had to wait for the ambulance. You never spent hours on the phone, pleading with the consultant’s secretary for an appointment. Poor mother! The thing she worried most about that day was the mud on her cardigan. She kept picking at it. ‘It doesn’t wash dear,’ she said as if she’d done something wrong. She never got to the top of the waiting list.

  Ade slid the laptop into her briefcase and got up.

  He held up his hand.

  ‘It doesn’t have to be like this, you know. Just hang on a moment.’

  He reached for the briefcase on the desk, flipped it open and extracted an envelope between two fingers. His eyes narrowed slightly as if he was calculating something.

  ‘Why don’t I give you this, just to help things along? A donation. Call it a Christmas present.’

  An image of her fist smashing into that plump self-assured face filled her mind.

  ‘Mr Webster!’ she said, nearly stuttering. ‘I can’t believe what you’re saying.’

  He waved a hand.

  ‘Never mind, just my joke. Only a Christmas card in there. Don’t take it to heart.’

  He reached down and slid the envelope into the briefcase, picked it up by the ends and h
eld it forward. She took hold of the handle but he didn’t release his grip.

  ‘Or perhaps we could go for a drink? To show there are no hard feelings.’

  He licked his lips. She stared hard at him and snatched back the case.

  ‘Excuse me.’ She turned to leave.

  ‘See you Thursday, if not before,’ he called after her. ‘Don’t forget.’

  She stood waiting for the lift, striving to contain her anger, to mould it into something she could use. Workers from the other offices were gathering round her, all talking past her, across her, all of them ignoring her. They recognised her instantly. Revenue. One of the enemy on their territory. They were all so sleek, so well-dressed, so certain of themselves. She’d been part of that world once, when it all made sense.

  The lift arrived and they crowded in front of her. A slender young man with greased back hair pushed past her. ‘I’m sorry,’ she said, dipping her head. He ignored her.

  ‘It’s no crime to be clumsy,’ her mother had said, and patted her hand. In this world it was. They judged you when you spilt your coffee in the coffee-shop, when you fumbled your change, when you bumped into someone in a queue.

  When she got to the lift the doors were already closing in front of her. The sleek young man was standing beside them. He smiled at her. She saw he had his finger on the close button.

  ‘Careful,’ he said as the doors slammed shut. There was something in the tone of his voice, courteous, powerful, at ease with himself. That was how Colin had sounded talking to cab-drivers, waiters, flight attendants. She turned and pushed open the door to the stair-case and stood there. She felt chill and suddenly exhausted. Why was she doing this? The image of her mother when they got her on the stretcher flashed into her mind, her mother lying there, frightened, her eyes pleading for help. Then Colin and the way he compressed his lips when she asked him what he did in the new job, and he just said ‘Spreadsheets. In the city.’ Then she thought of Webster holding out the briefcase, his eyes on her as if he owned her, the same way he owned everything else he touched.

  She gripped the rail and realised she still had her biro in her hand. She slipped it into her pocket and started down.

  2

  Ade sat back in her chair. She’d checked through all the calculations, all the algorithms and the modelling. She rubbed her hand across her eyes. She’d rewritten the assessment and added some references to precedents. Everything checked. She was right, she’d done everything the way Morwen had taught her, but they wouldn’t pay. They never did. That’s what broke Morwen’s spirit in the end, though she never said.

  She thought of Morwen and how they’d first met, two years ago. Ade wasn’t a fast-streamer; you didn’t get in the fast-stream when you did your degree part-time at Birkbeck. She knew she was as good as any of them, better than most, but she didn’t have that slick style, that bland assurance they taught you at Eton and Oxford. Morwen didn’t either, but she didn’t care and Ade learnt that from her.

  It was a bright spring day, her first day, and the wind had bustled her through the streets. She stepped out of the lift, her cheeks flushed, and there was Morwen: tall, nearly as tall as she was, with tightly curled black hair and dark earnest eyes, her hand held out in welcome.

  ‘Good to see you! I’m Morwen Archer, your mentor. Let’s get a coffee.’

  So many coffees, so many hours spent together, with Morwen explaining her ideas and how to make them work. The method. It was all Morwen’s work, although she gave Ade half the credit when they presented it to Denny.

  It was simple really.

  ‘Listen,’ said Morwen. ‘One in twenty businesses tells you their real profits – and those are the ones who’ve made a loss. No-one likes paying tax, so you pay your accountants and your profits shrink like an ice-cube in hot chocolate.’

  Ade shrugged, her hand on the table, palm open.

  ‘Where we go wrong is this: we try to work it out for each firm, look at their offices, the business they’re in, how the market’s going and so on. We make a guess, our best guess, and we negotiate. Downwards.’

  Morwen’s eyes sparkled.

  ‘The big mistake is to treat each firm as separate.’ She held up her fingers. ‘One, two three, four, like this. But they’re not just individual businesses, they’re a network. They all do deals with each other. They provide services, consultancy, trade, transfers – you scratch my back, I scratch your back. That’s how it works, that’s why they’re all here, next to each other, same office blocks, same clubs, same restaurants, all together in the city.’

  ‘Yes,’ said Ade, ‘but how does that help?’

  ‘Don’t you see? They trade, the money goes round and round, they’re all linked together.’

  Morwen took Ade’s hand and interlaced her fingers with hers.

  ‘It’s the same money. The profit of one is the business expense of another. So once we find out about one of them, we’re tracing part of the network. Takes time, but we find out more and more, we get better at it.’

  Ade kept her eyes on Morwen’s face. Morwen continued: ‘We catch one of them out and they have to pay a penalty, they don’t like that. We talk to them, do a deal. They tell us the truth about who they trade with, what’s really going on. We’ve got a bit more of the picture. We move on to the next one.’

  She laid Ade’s hand gently on the table.

  ‘The city is a network and we can track all the links in our spreadsheets. Bit by bit and not tomorrow, but we’ll do it, you and me.’

  So Morwen and Ade, Ade and Morwen became a team. They trained others. They got noticed. They started to build up the Model, who was making the mega-profits, where the money was going, who should pay the tax. They became friends; they always seemed to be together, in the office, in the coffee-shop, visiting galleries, hanging out. Morwen loved art and she loved the exhibitions, all that London had to show. They became part of each other’s lives.

  The Model, that’s what she’d had on the lap-top in Webster’s office. Morwen’s model. She’d do that for Morwen at least, just to show that someone remembered what she’d done. She sat there, thinking of Morwen, her solemn eyes, the smile on her face, the way she’d held Ade’s hand, the way she looked at you when she was talking to you, as if you mattered more than anyone else in the world. She thought of how Morwen had looked the last time she’d seen her, in Bronzefield High Security Prison, with both hands pressed against the security glass as if she’d be able to touch Ade again and her face slumped forward as she whispered: ‘You have to get me out of here, Ade. You have to get me out.’

  Spend every night for a month on a case, she thought, that’s what Morwen did. Check it and double check it, sitting here in an empty office, long after everyone else has gone. Put together a file, thick as a phone book, of evidence. Get it knocked back by some accountant you never even meet. Take it to the Commissioners and they look at you as if you’re nothing, just an interruption to the important business, and they turn it down in a sentence. In the end Morwen couldn’t take it. She cared about the job too much.

  Ade opened a memo form on the laptop and typed:

  ‘Re: R.Webster Consultancy.

  Accounts not credible. Request refer to Investigations, full audit. Model attached.’

  She tapped return. Somewhere behind her, at the other end of the office, the cleaners had started on the waste-bins.

  She thought of Webster, of the expression on his face when he handed her the briefcase. She flipped open another memo form.

  ‘Re: R.Webster Consultancy.

  Request transfer alternative case, grounds of incompatibility.’

  She sat there. Denny’s decision. Denny would call her in to talk it over. She never decided anything without talking it through. Ade pressed return and closed the machine.

  3

  She sat there t
hinking of Morwen, her skin dark and glossy as a ripe aubergine, her eyes thoughtful, her lips always smiling. It was after she’d met Morwen that she’d known she was going to do something worthwhile. She remembered one time, fairly early on, when they’d been working on the Model all morning and it didn’t balance and kept crashing and they’d missed lunch. In the end they’d gone for a coffee and they were at their favourite table in the window of the Gracechurch street coffee-bar, just opposite the office.

  Morwen took a bite out of her cup-cake and split the rest in half on the paper napkin.

  ‘You never told me about yourself, why you’re in the Revenue.’ She nodded towards the main office. ‘For most of them, it’s a job. Except perhaps Jimmy the Kid; he’s young, he thinks it’s an adventure. But you’re different.’

  Ade nodded. She picked up half of Morwen’s cake and put it carefully in her mouth. When she’d swallowed it she said: ‘I think I’m like you, Morwen. Something touched me and I’m not going to let it go. This is how I make a difference.’

  She fixed her eyes on Morwen’s. She hadn’t told anyone in the office about her family and she wasn’t going to. When they asked her, she just said her parents were teachers. Well, she’d learnt a lot from them.

  ‘My dad ran a betting shop. Numbers. That’s where the spreadsheets come from, I guess. He always told me: “you’ve got to look after yourself in this world. No-one’ll do it for you.” He thought he was a sharp businessman. He wasn’t much good at it, but when he had money he always gave me some. He wanted to do his best for me. So I spent the money on fees and books and worked and it got me through Birkbeck, just about.’

  She broke her cake in half. Morwen picked up a piece and bit into it.

  ‘Cherry and raisin, my favourite.’ She licked the crumbs off her fingers. ‘My Mum worked in a family centre. She always said we were the lucky ones. God put us here to look after anyone who was weak and vulnerable – frail elderly people, homeless people, families without anyone in a job – and that’s what she did. She said the welfare state didn’t come from heaven, it came because people cared and they paid for it.’