A Picture of Guilt Read online

  A Picture of Guilt

  A Picture of Guilt

  Libby Fischer Hellmann

  www.libbyhellmann.com

  Poisoned Pen Press

  Copyright © 2003 by Libby Fischer Hellmann

  First Edition 2003

  Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2003104004

  ISBN: 1-59058-073-7 Hardcover

  ISBN: 9781615950942 ePub

  A Picture of Guilt is a Berkeley original paperback publication and this hardcover edition has been published with the kind permission and cooperation, and is reprinted by arrangement with The Berkeley Publishing Group, a member of Penguin Group (USA) Inc.

  All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in, or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise) without the prior written permission of both the copyright owner and the publisher of this book.

  Poisoned Pen Press

  6962 E. First Ave., Ste. 103

  Scottsdale, AZ 85251

  www.poisonedpenpress.com

  [email protected]

  Dedication

  For Michael and Robin

  Acknowledgments

  This book would not exist without the input of many people, all of whom I owe a tremendous debt of gratitude. Especially Don Whiteman, whose knowledge, patience, and careful reading of the manuscript were a godsend. Also FBI Special Agent James Whitmer, Bob Egan, David Wechsler, Gerry Kessler, Leon Guaquil, Northbrook Deputy Commander Mike Green, Northfield Chief of Police Bill Lustig, Dave and Jean-Marie Case, and the Red Herrings.

  To Jacky Sach and Samantha Mandor: your insights and support are unparalleled—thanks for believing in Ellie. To Nora Cavin, I will always depend on your ear. And special thanks to Barbara Peters, TEE, who is really an angel in disguise.

  Epigraph

  Whoever destroys a single life is as guilty as though he had destroyed the entire world; and whoever rescues a single life earns as much merit as though he had rescued the entire world.

  —The Talmud, Mishna. Sanhedrin

  Contents

  Dedication

  Acknowledgments

  Epigraph

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Chapter 33

  Chapter 34

  Chapter 35

  Chapter 36

  Chapter 37

  Chapter 38

  Chapter 39

  Chapter 40

  Chapter 41

  Chapter 42

  Chapter 43

  Chapter 44

  Chapter 45

  Chapter 46

  Chapter 47

  More from this Author

  Contact Us

  Chapter One

  The raft plunged straight down and slammed into a wall of water. It flew up at a ninety-degree angle, propelling me up and out into the river. The rapids spun me around and threw me from side to side, burying me under a blanket of waves. I tried to right myself so I could rise to the surface, but I couldn’t tell which way was up. My lungs were on fire; my eyesight grew dim. Then a powerful force shoved me up, and I broke the surface, gasping for air.

  Feet up, legs straight. That’s what the guide said. I tried to stretch my legs out, but a fresh torrent wrenched me under. I tumbled over like a flimsy rag doll. Then, as if taunting me with the promise of release, the river raised me up again. Two giant boulders loomed ahead. I gulped down air and squeezed my eyes shut, certain my last sensation on earth would be the excruciating pain of bone splintering against rock.

  When I opened my eyes, the boulders were behind me. A surge of foam and spray had pushed me through a narrow channel between them. Above the roar of the rapids, I heard screams. I twisted around. Rachel! Twenty yards away, my thirteen-year-old’s yellow helmet bobbed in the churning waves.

  My stomach clenched. I lunged and thrashed my arms, trying to swim to her, but the rapids carried me in the opposite direction. Just before I went under, I saw the guide throw her a lifeline. It landed short. When I came up, she was gone.

  The river carried me another quarter mile. Then, as if underscoring its absolute control, it quieted. A hush descended. Tiny bubbles eddied across the surface. Gentle waves rippled peacefully. Hot sun struck my face.

  I didn’t care. Rachel was gone. I wanted to cry, but the tears wouldn’t come. I wanted to scream, but the sound died in my throat. I stopped struggling. The water had won.

  ***

  “I should have known, when they said the river was kicking butt.” I drained my third glass of wine.

  “It was up two feet from the big storm the other day,” Rachel added. She stirred her Coke with her swizzle stick.

  “But you survived,” Abdul, our dinner companion, said to Rachel.

  Her blond curls framed her face like a soft, golden cloud. They bounced as she nodded. “Another raft picked me up.”

  Rachel inherited her coloring from her father, but we share the same gray eyes and feisty ways. I pushed a strand of thick, black hair behind my ears, thinking how close I’d come to never seeing those curls again.

  “The guide said you weren’t in any real danger, with the life preservers and helmets,” David said.

  I glared. “What did you expect him to say?”

  We were finishing cocktails in the main dining room at the Greenbrier. Nestled in the backwoods of West Virginia, the resort is one of the plushest in the world. With its graceful columns, sculpted gardens, and antebellum buildings, it fairly drips Southern gentility.

  Which is why it sounded like a perfect idea when David asked us to meet him there for the Labor Day weekend. It would be a grand finale to summer, an elegant start to fall. It was also a chance for the three of us to spend time together, since Rachel and I live in Chicago. To bond, in that trying-each-other-out-as-family kind of way. I’d even started to look forward to the trip, imagining myself sipping mint juleps on the veranda in a frothy summer frock. Of course, I don’t have a frothy, mint-julep-sipping frock, but my friend Susan let me borrow hers. Susan has a dress for everything.

  “Another glass of wine?” Abdul asked.

  “I believe I will.”

  “Ellie,” David cut in. “Haven’t you had enough?”

  “Not yet.”

  Abdul Al Hamarani had appeared at exactly the right time, like a fairy-tale genie magically released from his bottle. He was buying film inside the rafting company’s small office as Rachel and I stumbled inside after our ordeal.

  “We should never have left the Greenbrier,” I’d muttered, collapsing on a chair.

  He turned around. Wearing khakis with sharp creases, a pressed shirt, and a safari vest, he looked like he’d stepped out of a J. Peterman catalog. “You are staying at the Greenbrier?”


  I nodded.

  “I am staying there as well.” He was round-faced, with dark hair slicked back from a widow’s peak and had he had wide, lively eyes. Pocketing his roll of film, he introduced himself and, after David joined us and settled up with the guide, insisted we drive back together in his rented Mercedes. David started to decline, but after our experience, I wasn’t eager for the bumpy ride in the van we’d come in. We accepted Abdul’s offer.

  During the trip we learned he was a Saudi petrochemical sheik and distant relative of the royal family. He’d come in a few days in advance of an annual energy conference, one of those international global-policy making forums the Greenbrier is famous for hosting.

  “I like to take pictures.” He pointed to a canvas bag that had been slung on his shoulder. “Even your harshest summer is a relief from what I’m used to.”

  We continued getting acquainted over dinner.

  “I beg your pardon, Ellie.” He had a slight British accent. “But given your…your attitude, why did you embark on this rafting adventure to begin with?” He’d changed into a Savile Row suit for dinner. The softness around his belly said he’d dined at some of the best restaurants in the world.

  “David suggested it.” In truth, I’d been looking forward to a lazy day on the river, the hot sun beating down, the smell of laurel perfuming the air. I’d been warned it was too late for the delicate pink and white blossoms, but there might be some white rhododendron—a first cousin—in bloom. As the state flower of West Virginia, rhododendron grows in wild profusion at the side of the road, in ravines, and on mountains. Even the pat of butter on our plates was sculpted into the flower.

  “Besides us, there were four teenagers. All of us first timers.” The waiter set a fresh glass of wine down in front of me. “Everything was fine at the beginning. The first rapid was only a two. Nothing to worry about. But then we got to the Keeneys. They’re the most powerful stretch of rapids on that part of the river.”

  I looked from Abdul to David, aware I was reworking and revising, turning the experience into a story. As if somehow that could blunt the terror I’d felt. But hey—I’m a filmmaker. I tell stories for a living.

  “So we hit the Keeneys, which usually are a four, but because of the rains the other day, were closer to a five. Apparently, when we hit the first patch, the kids got spooked and forgot to stroke. Big mistake.” I rolled my eyes and then clutched the arms of my chair. The room was starting to spin.

  “Yeah,” Rachel said. “Our guide kept telling us we had to keep stroking. All the way through the white water.”

  “If you stop, you lose control and balance, and you’re at the mercy of the water.” I took a sip of wine. “That’s what happened.”

  Abdul patted his mustache and carefully trimmed goatee. A band of gold around his wrist glinted in the candlelight. “Yet you proceeded down the rest of the river without incident?”

  David cleared his throat.

  I looked away. “Actually, I told them they would either have to get a helicopter in to pick me up, or I would be hiking back. And since there weren’t any helicopters handy—”

  “And you’re afraid to fly…” Rachel added.

  I shot her a look. “You hiked back with me.”

  “I didn’t want you to be alone.” She swirled the Coke in her glass. The corners of her mouth twitched with silent laughter.

  I settled back in my chair. The room was definitely starting to spin. I propped my elbows on the table. “One of the guides took us back. We climbed a fifty-foot cliff, then hiked five miles through the woods. That turned out to be the nicest part of the trip.”

  “Did you pass the abandoned railway and coal mines?” Abdul asked.

  I raised an eyebrow. “How did you know?”

  He thumbed his mustache. “I have been exploring the area myself.”

  “Of course. You said that.” I looked at David and saw just the slightest shake of his head.

  Abdul extracted a Gauloise from his pack and struck a match. Waving out the flame, he looked for an ashtray, but there was none. He casually dropped the spent match on the tablecloth. Our waiter, hovering nearby, promptly supplied an ashtray and whisked the match away, not even bothering to mention we were seated in the room’s nonsmoking section.

  Abdul didn’t seem to notice, either, and launched into a discussion with David about the Russian oil market. As the director of foreign currency trading for a Philadelphia bank, David keeps current on issues involving global finance. After their initial friction, they’d seemed to warm to each other.

  I stared at the spot where Abdul had dropped the match. A tiny smudge of gray marred the white damask tablecloth. I guess if you’re related to the Saudi royal family, you can do things like that. After a moment I decided the smudge wasn’t really jumping from one spot to another. I tried to focus on the men’s conversation but heard only snatches of words, soft music, and the clink of silver on china.

  I looked around. Ensconced in gilt-edged frames, a gentleman in a powdered wig and a lady in a low-cut gown gazed back at me. Did these stern representations of Southern society somehow sense my growing discomfort? After three days of rich food, soft accents, and scotch sprays, I was starting to feel overwhelmed. And that was before the river.

  A curl of smoke rose from Abdul’s cigarette, drifting into a haze above his head. I picked up a roll and buttered it, thinking how cruel it was to smash a tiny yellow flower with my butter knife. Who made those butterflowers anyway? Elves?

  “So,” I interrupted around a mouthful of bread. “You’re here for an energy conference?”

  Abdul looked over. “That’s correct.”

  “Yeah? So what do you think? Have you decided what the government is gonna do for you next year?” I swallowed clumsily.

  Irritation flashed in David’s eyes. Rachel looked away.

  “Don’t look at me that way, David. Everybody knows the oil industry’s in bed with the government. And—” I spread my hands. “What better place to be seduced? I mean, here we are in the lap of luxury in the poorest state in the country. And why is it so poor, you ask? Because all the coal that was so abundant here was stolen by certain interests while our government looked the other way.”

  “Ellie, that’s enough.”

  “That’s why those coal mines are abandoned, you know.” I wagged a finger. “They were exploited by rich and powerful capitalishhts who didn’t care what happened to the land after they raped it. And now they’re shhtarting all over again with timber.” I nodded in what I hoped was a sage manner. “Logging.”

  Abdul’s mustache and goatee seemed to blur together.

  “So you see, it’s entirely fitting your meeting’s at the Greenbrier,” I went on. “Hey. I got an idea. Why don’t we make a commercial? ‘The Greenbrier—where the government goes to get grafted.’” I looked from Abdul to David. “Has a ring to it, don’cha think?”

  Abdul inhaled deeply, the embers of his cigarette glowing orange. David avoided my eyes.

  “You have passionate convictions, Ellie,” Abdul said. “But you give me too much credit. I am just an observer, not a player in your politics.” He picked up the menu. “Perhaps we should order our dinner.”

  ***

  After dinner Rachel headed to the bowling alley, where the kids at the resort hung out. David and I went to our suite: two large bedrooms and a lavishly decorated living room with a wraparound porch outside.

  David loosened his tie and disappeared into the bedroom. I sprawled on the living room couch. He came back out, minus his jacket, and sat on the other end. I made no move toward him, which, even through my alcoholic haze, surprised me. Usually, I can’t wait to get him alone. He gazed at me expectantly, his deep blue eyes wide. Soft lamplight glinted off his thick, white hair. Muscles bulged through his short-sleeved shirt. Though he was well into his fifties, he could hold his own with any Generation Xer. The silence between us grew. Then,

  “Why do you always do that?” he said.


  “What?” I said, after a beat. “Get drunk?”

  He shook his head. “Why do you always make sure everyone knows you’re an outsider?”

  “I am.”

  “No more than Abdul.”

  “Sure. And I just happen to have twenty oil wells in my pocket, too.” I sniffed. “My God, David, look at this place. The garbage alone could feed an entire West Virginia hamlet. And Abdul flicks his burnt match on the table like we’re in some greasy spoon. I know some people are used to being waited on. But that just isn’t me.” I slouched. “Of course, nearly drowning today didn’t help much.”

  David took a breath. “Ellie, I wanted us to enjoy our time together. Frightening you or Rachel was the last thing I ever intended to do.”

  That was probably as close as he would come to admitting that we had brushed up against the void that afternoon. “But as far as belonging…” He sighed. “People spend their whole lives not knowing where they belong. Can’t you just file this away as an experience?”

  Maybe I was still too worked up. Or drunk. But his tone rankled. “Sorry. I forgot who I was dealing with. The guy who’ll do anything to belong. Who needs acceptance from everyone.”

  He knelt in front of me. “Not from everyone,” he said quietly. “Just you.”

  Something inside me came unhinged, and a weight in my chest I hadn’t known was there began to melt.

  “I’m sorry. That was way out of line.”

  “It’s okay.” He smiled and drew me into his arms.

  Chapter Two

  “Ellie?”

  Abdul headed over to my table carrying a plate loaded with French toast, sausage, and grits. Draper’s Café was done up in so many bright pinks and greens I felt like a prisoner inside the petals of a giant laurel. I folded my newspaper. “Good morning.”

  “Where’s David?”

  “Showering. He was working out.”

  Abdul’s mound of food almost obscured the pattern of laurels bordering his plate. He smiled ruefully as he set it down. “I should follow his example. But I am not as disciplined.”