Lincoln Read online

  NATIONAL BESTSELLER

  “A grand work—the Lincoln biography for this generation.”

  —Arthur Schlesinger, Jr.

  In this beautifully rendered and stunningly original portrait of the sixteenth president, Lincoln emerges as both a great leader and an imperfect human being—a vigorous man beset by personal and political troubles who weathered them all to become America’s most revered president. Drawing extensively from Lincoln’s personal papers and from newly discovered records of Lincoln’s legal practice, David Herbert Donald brilliantly re-creates the president’s rise from obscurity to the heights of political glory. He explains how Lincoln’s personal and public lives adversely affected each other, how the president felt events were beyond his control, and how, despite everything, this inexperienced and ill-prepared man grew into a chief executive of extraordinary political acumen and moral greatness. Like Donald’s other two Pulitzer Prize–winning biographies, Lincoln is destined to become a classic of its kind.

  “Lincoln immediately takes its place among the best of the genre, and it is unlikely that it will be surpassed in elegance, incisiveness and originality in this century. . . . A book of investigative tenacity, interpretive boldness and almost acrobatic balance.”

  —Harold Holzer, Chicago Tribune

  “Eagerly awaited, Lincoln fulfills expectations. Donald writes with lucidity and elegance.”

  —James M. McPherson, The Atlantic Monthly

  “A one-volume study of Lincoln’s life that will augment and replace the previous modern standards by Benjamin Thomas (1953) and Stephen Oates (1977). Donald’s Lincoln is a scholarly achievement.”

  —David W. Blight, Los Angeles Times

  DAVID HERBERT DONALD is the Charles Warren Professor Emeritus of American History and American Civilization at Harvard University. Author of Lincoln’s Herndon, Lincoln Reconsidered, The Civil War and Reconstruction, and We Are Lincoln Men, and editor of Why the North Won the Civil War, he has twice won the Pulitzer Prize for biography: in 1961 for Charles Sumner and the Coming of the Civil War, and in 1988 for Look Homeward: A Life of Thomas Wolfe. He lives in Lincoln, Massachusetts.

  Cover design by David Ter-Avanesyan

  Cover photograph © The Granger Collection, New York

  Author photograph by David Schaefar

  Register online at www.SimonandSchuster.com for more

  information on this and other great books.

  Thank you for purchasing this Simon & Schuster eBook.

  Sign up for our newsletter and receive special offers, access to bonus content, and info on the latest new releases and other great eBooks from Simon & Schuster.

  or visit us online to sign up at

  eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com

  ALSO BY DAVID HERBERT DONALD

  Look Homeward: A Life of Thomas Wolfe

  Liberty and Union: The Crisis of Popular Government, 1830–1890

  The Great Republic: A History of the American People

  (with Bernard Bailyn, David Brion Davis, Robert Dallek,

  John L. Thomas, Gordon S. Wood, and Robert H. Wiebe)

  Gone for a Soldier: The Civil War Memoirs

  of Private Alfred Bellard (editor)

  Charles Sumner and the Rights of Man

  The Nation in Crisis, 1861–1877

  The Politics of Reconstruction, 1863–1867

  Diary of Charles Francis Adams: Volume I, January 1820-June 1825,

  and Volume II, July 1825-September 1829

  (editor with Aïda DiPace Donald)

  The Civil War and Reconstruction (with J. G. Randall)

  Why the North Won the Civil War (editor)

  Charles Sumner and the Coming of the Civil War

  Lincoln Reconsidered: Essays on the Civil War Era

  Divided We Fought: A Pictorial History of the War, 1861–1865

  (with others)

  Inside Lincoln’s Cabinet: The Civil War Diaries of Salmon P. Chase

  Lincoln’s Herndon

  FOR AÏDA AND BRUCE,

  WHO HAVE HAD TO LIVE WITH LINCOLN

  FOR MOST OF THEIR LIVES

  SIMON & SCHUSTER PAPERBACKS

  ROCKEFELLER CENTER

  1230 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS

  NEW YORK, NY 10020

  www.Simonschuster.com

  COPYRIGHT © 1995 BY DAVID HERBERT DONALD ALL RIGHTS RESERVED, INCLUDING THE RIGHT OF REPRODUCTION IN WHOLE OR IN PART IN ANY FORM.

  SIMON & SCHUSTER PAPERBACKS AND COLOPHON ARE REGISTERED TRADEMARKS OF SIMON & SCHUSTER, INC.

  DESIGNED BY LEVAVI AND LEVAVI

  THE LIBRARY OF CONGRESS HAS CATALOGED THE HARDCOVER EDITION AS FOLLOWS:

  DONALD, DAVID HERBERT, DATE.

  LINCOLN / DAVID HERBERT DONALD.

  P. CM.

  INCLUDES BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES (P. ) AND INDEX.

  1. LINCOLN, ABRAHAM, 1809-1865.

  2. PRESIDENTS——UNITED STATES——BIOGRAPHY. I. TITLE.

  E457.D66 1995

  973.7&092—DC20

  [B] 95-4782 CIP

  ISBN-13: 978-0-684-80846-8

  ISBN-10: 0-684-80846-3

  ISBN-13: 978-0-684-82535-9 (PBK)

  ISBN-10: 0-684-82535-X (PBK)

  ISBN-13: 978-1-43912-628-8 (ebook)

  Frontispiece: Lincoln considered this photograph, made by Alexander Hesler of Chicago in February 1857, “a very true one,” but Mary Lincoln and others did not like it. “My impression,” Lincoln said, “is that their objection arises from the disordered condition of the hair.” (Lloyd Ostendorf Collection)

  I CLAIM NOT TO HAVE CONTROLLED EVENTS,

  BUT CONFESS PLAINLY THAT EVENTS

  HAVE CONTROLLED ME.

  Abraham Lincoln to Albert G. Hodges,

  April 4, 1864

  Contents

  Preface

  CHAPTER ONE • Annals of the Poor

  CHAPTER TWO • A Piece of Floating Driftwood

  CHAPTER THREE • Cold, Calculating, Unimpassioned Reason

  CHAPTER FOUR • Always a Whig

  CHAPTER FIVE • Lone Star of Illinois

  CHAPTER SIX • At the Head of His Profession in This State

  CHAPTER SEVEN • There Are No Whigs

  CHAPTER EIGHT • A House Divided

  CHAPTER NINE • The Taste Is in My Mouth

  CHAPTER TEN • An Accidental Instrument

  CHAPTER ELEVEN • A People’s Contest

  CHAPTER TWELVE • The Bottom Is Out of the Tub

  CHAPTER THIRTEEN • An Instrument in God’s Hands

  CHAPTER FOURTEEN • A Pumpkin in Each End of My Bag

  CHAPTER FIFTEEN • What Will the Country Say!

  CHAPTER SIXTEEN • A New Birth of Freedom

  CHAPTER SEVENTEEN • The Greatest Question Ever Presented to Practical Statesmanship

  CHAPTER EIGHTEEN • It Was Not Best to Swap Horses

  CHAPTER NINETEEN • I Am Pretty Sure-Footed

  CHAPTER TWENTY • With Charity for All

  CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE • I Will Take Care of Myself

  Photographs

  Sources and Notes

  Index

  * * *

  Maps

  Lincoln’s Early Years in Kentucky, Indiana, and Illinois

  Lincoln’s Illinois

  Territorial Expansion and Slavery, 1819–1854 between

  Eastern Campaigns of the Civil War, 1861–1865

  Major Engagements of the Civil War, 1861–1865 between

  Preface

  The only time I ever met President John F. Kennedy, in February 1962, he was unhappy with historians. A group of scholars had been in the Oval Office hoping to enlist him in a poll that ranked American presidents. I was not one of those visitors, but the next day when I gave a talk in the White House about
Abraham Lincoln, the subject was much on his mind. He voiced his deep dissatisfaction with the glib way the historians had rated some of his predecessors as “Below Average” and marked a few as “Failures.” Thinking, no doubt, of how his own administration would look in the backward glance of history, he resented the whole process. With real feeling he said, “No one has a right to grade a President—not even poor James Buchanan—who has not sat in his chair, examined the mail and information that came across his desk, and learned why he made his decisions.”

  This book was conceived in the spirit of President Kennedy’s observations. In tracing the life of Abraham Lincoln, I have asked at every stage of his career what he knew when he had to take critical actions, how he evaluated the evidence before him, and why he reached his decisions. It is, then, a biography written from Lincoln’s point of view, using the information and ideas that were available to him. It seeks to explain rather than to judge.

  My biography is based largely on Lincoln’s own words, whether in his letters and messages or in conversations recorded by reliable witnesses. I have tried as far as possible to write from the original sources—that is, from firsthand contemporary accounts by people who saw and talked with the President. Of course, I have consulted the voluminous secondary literature, but I have used it chiefly for letters and documents that I could not find elsewhere. My approach was made possible by the availability of the Abraham Lincoln Papers in the Library of Congress (now fortunately on microfilm). After use by Lincoln’s authorized biographers, John G. Nicolay and John Hay, in 1890, these papers were sealed until 1947 and therefore could not be consulted for the major biographies by Albert J. Beveridge, William E. Barton, Carl Sandburg, and J. G. Randall.*

  The results of my inquiries can most readily be defined in negative terms. This book is not a general history of the United States during the middle of the nineteenth century. I have stuck close to Lincoln, who was only indirectly connected with the economic and social transformations of the period. It is not even a history of the Civil War. There is, for example, almost nothing in the following pages about the internal affairs of the Confederacy, because these were matters that Lincoln could not know about. It is not a military history; I have not described campaigns and battles that Lincoln did not witness. I have not offered a broad philosophical discussion of the origins of the Civil War and I have not addressed the question of whether it was the first modern war. These are important subjects, but they did not present themselves to Abraham Lincoln in any practical way. I have not asked whether Lincoln freed the slaves or the slaves freed themselves, because Lincoln never considered these roads to emancipation as mutually exclusive. Certainly he knew that thousands of slaves, in individual heroic acts of rebellion, were leaving their masters to seek freedom behind the Union lines, but he also knew that ending the institution of slavery required official action on the part of the United States government.

  In focusing closely on Lincoln himself—on what he knew, when he knew it, and why he made his decisions—I have, I think, produced a portrait rather different from that in other biographies. It is perhaps a bit more grainy than most, with more attention to his unquenchable ambition, to his brain-numbing labor in his law practice, to his tempestuous married life, and to his repeated defeats. It suggests how often chance, or accident, played a determining role in shaping his life. And it emphasizes his enormous capacity for growth, which enabled one of the least experienced and most poorly prepared men ever elected to high office to become the greatest American President.

  More important, this biography highlights a basic trait of character evident throughout Lincoln’s life: the essential passivity of his nature. Lincoln himself recognized it in a letter he wrote on April 4, 1864, to Albert G. Hodges, a fellow Kentuckian, who asked him to explain why he had shifted from his inaugural pledge not to interfere with slavery to a policy of emancipation. After relating how circumstances had obliged him to change his mind—how emancipation and the use of African-American soldiers had become military necessities—the President concluded: “In telling this tale I attempt no compliment to my own sagacity. I claim not to have controlled events, but confess plainly that events have controlled me.”

  From his earliest days Lincoln had a sense that his destiny was controlled by some larger force, some Higher Power. Turning away from orthodox Christianity because of the emotional excesses of frontier evangelicalism, he found it easier as a young man to accept what was called the Doctrine of Necessity, which he defined as the belief “that the human mind is impelled to action, or held in rest by some power, over which the mind itself has no control.” Later he frequently quoted to his partner, William H. Herndon, the lines from Hamlet:

  There’s a divinity that shapes our ends,

  Rough-hew them how we will.

  From Lincoln’s fatalism derived some of his most lovable traits: his compassion, his tolerance, his willingness to overlook mistakes. That belief did not, of course, lead him to lethargy or dissipation. Like thousands of Calvinists who believed in predestination, he worked indefatigably for a better world—for himself, for his family, and for his nation. But it helped to buffer the many reverses that he experienced and enabled him to continue a strenuous life of aspiration.

  It also made for a pragmatic approach to problems, a recognition that if one solution was fated not to work another could be tried. “My policy is to have no policy” became a kind of motto for Lincoln—a motto that infuriated the sober, doctrinaire people around him who were inclined to think that the President had no principles either. He might have offended his critics less if he had more often used the analogy he gave James G. Blaine when explaining his course on Reconstruction: “The pilots on our Western rivers steer from point to point as they call it—setting the course of the boat no farther than they can see; and that is all I propose to myself in this great problem.”

  Both statements suggest Lincoln’s reluctance to take the initiative and make bold plans; he preferred to respond to the actions of others. They also show why Lincoln in his own distinctively American way had the quality John Keats defined as forming “a Man of Achievement,” that quality “which Shakespeare possessed so enormously... Negative Capability, that is when a man is capable of being in uncertainties, Mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason.”

  Much of the research for this biography was made possible through a generous grant from the Division of Research Programs of the National Endowment for the Humanities (Grant No. RO-2128–89). I am particularly indebted to Charles Ambler and George R. Lucas, Jr., in that division for their assistance.

  I am also grateful to Dean Henry Rosovsky, Dean Michael Spence, and Dean Phyllis Keller, who were instrumental in arranging leaves of absence from my teaching duties at Harvard University.

  Throughout the project I was fortunate to have the assistance of Laura Nakatsuka, who not merely performed expert secretarial services but proved a highly efficient research sleuth, uncovering Lincoln items in a dozen or more manuscript collections.

  Several gifted Harvard undergraduate and graduate students have performed invaluable work as research assistants who scoured the newspapers and periodicals for material on Lincoln, and I am indebted to them all: Richard Bennett, Steven Chen, Martin Fitzpatrick, Elaine Goldenberg, Sally Hadden, Zachary Karabell, Timothy McCarthy, Matthew Pinsker, Gerald Prokopowicz, and Ronald Ryan.

  The tedious work of verifying facts and checking quotations in my manuscript fell to Thomas J. Brown, Fred Dalzell, and Michael Vorenberg, and I thank all three for helping me to eliminate errors of fact and interpretation. Mr. Vorenberg, who is preparing the authoritative history of the Thirteenth Amendment, offered incisive criticisms that have greatly influenced my treatment of colonization and emancipation. On legal and constitutional issues I have profited much from Dr. Brown’s unfailingly helpful suggestions.

  To the blessed librarians everywhere my obligation is great. As always, Nathaniel Bunker, the Charles W
arren Bibliographer at Harvard University, has been responsive to my needs for nineteenth-century American newspapers and manuscripts on microfilm. Thomas F. Schwartz, state historian of Illinois, graciously made available the immense resources of the Henry Horner Collection at the Illinois State Historical Library and patiently answered my frequent questions. Cheryl Schnirring did the same for the manuscript collections in that same great library, and Cheryl Pence assisted in my search for nineteenth-century Illinois newspapers. John Hoffmann was my gracious host at the Illinois Historical Survey in Urbana. At the Chicago Historical Society, Theresa A. McGill provided invaluable assistance, and Sherry Byrne of the University of Chicago Library helped me locate newspaper files. Dallas R. Lindgren served as my guide to the rich collections of the Minnesota Historical Society. At the Huntington Library, John H. Rhode-hamel, Lita Garcia, and Karen E. Kearns were helpful in securing microfilm of important manuscript collections. Daniel Weinberg and Thomas Trescott of the Abraham Lincoln Book Shop in Chicago have energetically assisted me in dozens of bibliographical searches.

  At the Lincoln Legal Papers, perhaps the most important archival investigation now under way in the United States, I was welcomed by the director, Cullom Davis, and by the assistant editor, William Beard, and was given full access to the enormous treasure-house of legal documents that they have built up.